CBD Flowers in Italy: What is the Court of Cassation Really Changing?

drapeau italien

A recent decision by the Italian Court of Cassation is circulating widely in the European hemp sector, and not just in Italy. Some headlines suggest that CBD flowers have become legal again in the country. This isn't quite right: the judges haven't authorized the sale of hemp; they have simply regulated how authorities can confiscate stocks. Before diving into the details of this Italian case, it's important to understand that it's part of a much broader debate that also affects French and Belgian shops.

A debate that goes far beyond Italy

Hemp travels poorly from one European country to another legally: each member state sets its own rules, sometimes very different from one another, for the same plant produced under comparable conditions. This is exactly what the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled in November 2020, in the so-called Kanavape case (C-663/18). Two entrepreneurs from Marseille were prosecuted for selling CBD products in France that were legally manufactured in the Czech Republic. The CJEU established a key principle: a member state cannot ban the marketing of CBD legally produced elsewhere in the Union, unless it can demonstrate that this ban is both necessary for public health and proportionate. It was on this basis that the Aix-en-Provence Court of Appeal finally acquitted the two defendants. This ruling didn't concern raw flowers themselves, but it set a reasoning framework that is resurfacing today in the Italian case.

Why has Italy banned hemp flowers since 2025?

Italy has taken a different path than France. The Decree-Law No. 48 of April 11, 2025 (the "decreto sicurezza"), converted by Law No. 80 of June 9, 2025, criminally prohibits the import, sale, transport, and processing of hemp inflorescences, as well as the oils, resins, and extracts derived from them. This text, in Article 18, modified Law No. 242/2016 which previously regulated industrial hemp. The fundamental difference with France: Italy bases its ban on the nature of the product (the flower itself), and not solely on its THC level.

The case behind the decision

The case involved a seizure of hemp, where 73 samples were tested; 29 exceeded the 0.5% THC threshold. However, experts estimated that this level was not enough to demonstrate a concrete narcotic effect, a central criterion in Italian criminal law known as the principle of offensivity, which requires a real psychotropic effect and not just a number on a label. Following this reasoning, the Modena court dismissed the offense but still refused to return the goods, considering that the flowers had anyway become "off-market" since Article 18 came into force.

It is this contradiction that the Court of Cassation penalized: you cannot acknowledge the absence of a narcotic effect on one hand and hold the goods indefinitely on the other without precise legal justification. The case was sent back to the Modena court for a new review; the Court itself did not order the restitution.

What this decision changes, and what it doesn't

Three rules emerge from the ruling: a hemp inflorescence cannot be automatically confiscated just because it is a flower; a confiscation must be based on a specific legal text; and the offense must be proven by concrete evidence rather than presumed. This is a clarification of criminal procedure, not a decriminalization.

Conversely, the decision legalizes nothing: it creates no right to sell, transport, or process flowers, and it leaves Article 18 fully in force. Other Italian courts, such as the one in Sassari, had already adopted similar reasoning, judging that the mere presence of flowers or leaves was not enough to characterize illegal drug production—a position confirmed after the prosecution's appeal was ruled inadmissible.

A legal battle that is far from over

This decision is just one episode among many. According to Canapa Sativa Italia, an investigating judge in Brindisi has referred the matter to the Italian Constitutional Court, arguing that Article 18 is problematic on three levels: its insertion into a security text without a direct link or demonstrated urgency, the failure to respect the principle of offensivity since it presumes an offense without verifying a real effect, and a possible contradiction with the free movement of goods guaranteed by European law. At the same time, the Italian Council of State has referred the matter to the CJEU to determine if these restrictions are compatible with that same free movement and with the common agricultural policy. Neither of these two procedures has been decided yet.

What this changes for consumers and shops in France

Nothing, directly. An Italian court decision has no legal standing outside of Italy.

In France, the framework remains the one set by the Council of State, which on December 29, 2022, overturned the general ban on raw hemp flowers and leaves with low THC content: products must come from authorized varieties of Cannabis sativa L., respect the 0.3% THC limit, and be accompanied by batch traceability, without therapeutic claims. On the question that Italy is still asking itself, France has therefore already ruled, and in a more favorable direction.

In conclusion

This decision represents a procedural step forward for hemp professionals in Italy, but it does not legalize CBD flowers in the country. It is part of a broader dispute, with the Italian Constitutional Court and the CJEU still considering the matter, continuing a European debate already opened by the Kanavape ruling. For consumers and shops in France and Belgium, nothing changes: the frameworks set respectively by the Council of State and the FAMHP remain fully applicable.